SUPREME COURT JUSTICE Question: Shall each of the persons ...

1 The Judicial Evaluation Results of the Chicago Council of Lawyers for Judges Seeking Retention on the November 6, 2018 Ballot (in ballot order). SUPREME COURT JUSTICE Question: Shall each of the persons listed be retained in office as a Judge of the Appellate COURT , First Judicial Anne M. Burke YES District, or of the Cook County circuit COURT ? APPELLATE COURT JUDGE. Margaret Stanton McBride YES. circuit COURT JUDGE Daniel R. Degnan YES. Kathy M. Flanagan NO John H. Ehrlich YES. Moshe Jacobius YES Terry Gallagher YES. Stuart F. Lubin YES William G. Gamboney YES. Martin S. Agran YES Elizabeth Mary Hayes YES. Ronald F. Bartkowicz YES Martin C. Kelley YES. E. Kenneth Wright, Jr. YES Kimberly D. Lewis YES.

2 Catherine Marie Haberkorn YES Edward M. Maloney YES. James M. Varga YES Lisa Ann Marino YES. Marcia Maras YES Michael Tully Mullen YES. Peter Flynn YES Karen Lynn O'Malley YES. Paul A. Karkula YES Paul V. Pavlus YES. Maura Slattery Boyle NO Cynthia Ramirez YES. Mary Margaret Brosnahan YES. Beatriz Santiago YES. Matthew E. Coghlan NO. Joyce Marie Murphy-Gorman YES. Joan Margaret O'Brien YES Judicial Evaluations of the Chicago Council Thomas David Roti YES of Lawyers in Races to Fill Judicial Colleen F. Sheehan YES Vacancies Carl Anthony Walker YES (D) = Democratic (R) = Republican Daniel Patrick Brennan YES. Grace G. Dickler YES Evaluation of Candidates for the circuit COURT in the Ellen L. Flannigan YES Countywide Elections (all ballots).

3 Carol M. Howard YES. Jill C. Marisie YES Hon. Eileen Mary Brewer Vacancy James Michael McGing YES (D) Kathryn M. Vahey Qualified Mike McHale YES. James Patrick Murphy YES Hon. Evelyn B. Clay Vacancy Thomas W. Murphy YES (D) Kathaleen T. Lanahan Qualified Ramon Ocasio III YES. Mary Colleen Roberts YES Hon. Deborah M. Dooling Vacancy Diane M. Shelley YES (D) Tom Sam Sianis Qualified Celia Louise Gamrath YES. Lorna Ellen Propes YES Hon. Lynn M. Egan Tommy Brewer YES (D) Rosa Maria Silva Qualified Andrea M. Schleifer YES Hon. Laurence J. Dunford Vacancy Thomas R. Allen YES (D) Thomas Francis McQuire Qualified Erica L. Reddick YES. Hon. Thomas E. Flanagan Vacancy Aicha Marie MacCarthy YES. (D) Hon. Preston Jones, Jr.

4 Qualified Lionel Jean-Baptiste YES. Michael R. Clancy YES Hon. Russell W. Hartigan Vacancy Regina Ann Scannicchio YES (D) Cecilia A. Horan Qualified Diann Karen Marsalek YES (CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 -- OVER). Pamela M. Leeming YES. Larry G. Axelrood YES. Carl B. Boyd YES. Page 2. Evaluation of Candidates for the circuit COURT in the Sixth Subcircuit (Hon. Robert Lopez Cepero Vacancy). Countywide Elections (all ballots) (D) Linda Perez Qualified (continued). Eighth Subcircuit (Hon. Candace J. Fabri Vacancy). Hon. Michelle D. Jordan Vacancy (D) James A. Shapiro Qualified (D) Hon. Clare Joyce Quish Qualified Eighth Subcircuit (Hon. Laura C. Liu Vacancy). Hon. Sheila McGinnis Vacancy (D) Lindsay Christopher Huge Qualified (D) Hon.

5 Peter Michael Gonzalez Not Qualified Eighth Subcircuit (Sheryl A. Pethers Vacancy). Hon Jean Prendergast Rooney Vacancy (D) Jeanne Marie Wrenn Qualified (D) John Joseph Hagerty Qualified Tenth Subcircuit (Hon. Eileen O'Neill Burke Vacancy). (D) Stephanie Saltouros Qualified Evaluation of Candidates for the circuit COURT in the Subcircuit Elections Tenth Subcircuit (Hon. Donald J. Suriano Vacancy). (D) Colleen Reardon Daly Qualified First Subcircuit (Hon. Orville E. Hambright Vacancy). (D) Erika Lynn Orr Qualified Eleventh Subcircuit (Hon. Kathleen G. Kennedy Vacancy). Second Subcircuit (Hon. Bertina E. Lampkin Vacancy) (D) Joanne F. Rosado Qualified (D) Tiana Ellis Blakely Qualified Twelve Subcircuit (Hon.)

6 William O. Maki Vacancy). Second Subcircuit (Hon. Marjorie C. Laws Vacancy) (R) David Studenroth Qualified (D) Hon. Adrienne E. Davis Qualified (D) Joel Chupack Qualified Second Subcircuit ( L. Rhodes Vacancy) Thirteenth Subcircuit (Hon. Clayton Crane Vacancy). (D) Hon. Toya T. Harvey Qualified (R) Gary William Seyring Qualified (D) Ketki Kay Steffen Qualified Second Subcircuit (Hon. John D. Turner, Jr. Vacancy). (D) Ieshia Eshale Gray Qualified Thirteenth Subcircuit (Hon. Jeffrey Lawrence Vacancy). (R) Daniel Patrick Fitzgerald Qualified Second Subcircuit (Hon. Camille E. Willis Vacancy) (D) Shannon 'Malley Not Recommended (D) Hon. Debra A. Seaton Qualified (refused to be evaluated). Second Subcircuit (Hon.

7 Valerie Turner Vacancy) Thirteenth Subcircuit (Hon. Ann O'Donnell Vacancy). (D) Arthur W. Willis Qualified (R) Christine Svenson Qualified (D) Samuel J. Betar III Qualified Third Subcircuit (Hon. Maureen F. Delehanty Vacancy). (D) Kevin Patrick Cunningham Qualified Fourteenth Subcircuit (Hon. Rodolfo Garcia Vacancy). (D) Beatriz A. Frausto-Sandoval Not Qualified Fourth Subcircuit (Hon. Thomas M. Davy Vacancy). (D) Hon. David R. Navarro Well Qualified Fifteenth Subcircuit (Hon. George Scully, Jr. Vacancy). (D) Michael B. Barrett Qualified Fourth Subcircuit (Hon. James G. Riley Vacancy). (D) Elizabeth Ciaccia-Lezza Qualified Fifteenth Subcircuit (Hon. Frank G. Zelezinski Vacancy). (R) Karla Marie Fiaoni Qualified Fifth Subcircuit (Hon.

8 Patricia Banks Vacancy) (D) Scott McKenna Qualified (D) Hon. H. Yvonne Coleman Qualified _____. Fifth Subcircuit (Hon. Rickey Jones Vacancy). (D) Hon. Marian Emily Perkins Qualified You may read and/or download a copy of the Council's judicial evaluation report at the websites, Fifth Subcircuit (Hon. Edward Washington III Vacancy) or at (D) Hon. Robert Harris Qualified To request more information by phone or by fax, please Sixth Subcircuit (Hon. Gloria Chevere Vacancy) call 312-988-6565. (D) Hon. Kent Delgado Well Qualified Sixth Subcircuit (Hon. Richard C. Cooke Vacancy). (D) Andrea M. Webber Qualifi