Transcription of CASES AND MATERIALS ON CRIMINAL LAW - Willkommen
1 CASES AND MATERIALSON CRIMINAL LAWSECOND EDITION compiled byJONATHAN BURCHELLBA LLB (Natal) LLM Dip in Comparative Legal Studies (Cantab)PhD (Wits)Professor of Law in the School of Law,University of Natal, PietermaritzburgFellow of the University of NatalandJOHN MILTONBA LLM PhD (Natal)Professor of Law in the School of Law,University of Natal, PietermaritzburgFellow of the University of NatalJuta&Co, LtdContentsPagePreface to the First Edition iiiPreface to the Second Edition vTable of CASES xixLegislation xxviiCommissions of Enquiry
2 XxviiPART ONEI ntroductionCONSTITUTIONAL DIMENSIONS[I] The Bill of Rights 1 THE PRINCIPLE OF LEGALITY[2] SvFrancis 1994(1)SACR350(C) 12 PUNISHMENTC apital Punishment[3] SvMakwanyanel995(2)SACRl(CC) 14 Corporal Punishment[4] Sv Williams 1995 (3) SACR 632 (CO 42 PART TWOG eneral Principles of CRIMINAL LiabilityUNLAWFUL CONDUCTV oluntary Conduct[5] SvJOHNSON1969(l)SA201(A) 55[6] S v CHRETIEN 1981 (1)SA 1097 (A) 56[7] RvDHLAMINI 1955 (1)SA 120 (T) 56[8] RvMKEE1959(2)SA260(N))
3 58[9] RvSCHOONWINKEL1953(3)SA136(C) 62[10] SvSTELLMACHER1982(2)SA181(SWA) 63[II] SvVANRENSBURG 1987(3)SA35(T) 63[12] RvVICTOR 1943 TPD77 64 Omissions[13] MINISTER VAN POLISIE v EWELS 1975 (3) SA 590 (A) 65[14] S v FERNANDEZ 1966 (2) SA 259 (A) 67[15] MINISTER OF POLICE v SKOSANA1977 (1) SA 31 (A) 68[16] RvCHENJERE 1960(1)SA473(FC) 68VU1 Contents[17] S v VAN AS 1967 (4) SA 594 (A) 69[18] SvGABA1981(3)SA745(O)
4 69[19] S vRUSSELL 1967 (3) SA739 (N) 70[20] COMMENT ON MINISTER OF LAW AND ORDER v KADIR 72 State of Affairs[21] R v VAN ACHTERDAM 1911 EDL 336 78[22] SvBRICK1973(2)SA571(A) 78 Causation[23] MINISTER OF POLICE v SKOSANA 1977 (1)SA 31 (A) 81[24] SvHAARMEYER1971(3)SA43(A) 87[25] S vMBAMBO 1965 (2) SA845 (A) 87[26] SvDANIELS 1983(3)SA275(A) 89[27] SvMOKGETHI1990(l)SA32(A)
5 100[28] INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING CO (PTY) LTD v BENTLEY1990 (1) SA 680(A) 112[29] SvMAZIBUKO 1988(3)SA 190(A) 114[30] SvMADIKANE 1990(1) SACR 377 (N) 115[31] SvVANAS1967(4)SA594(A) 116[32] S v WILLIAMS 1986 (4) SA 1188 (A) 118[33] EX PARTE DIE MINISTER VAN JUSTISIE.
6 IN RE S v GROTJOHN 1970(2) SA355 (A) 121[34] SvKHOZA1982(3)SA1019(A) 124 DEFENCES EXCLUDING UNLAWFULNESSI ntroduction[35] SvCHRETIEN 1981 (1)SA 1097(A) 125[36] S v GABA 1981 (3) SA 745 (O) 125[37] CLARKE v HURST NO 1992 (4) SA 630 (D) 125[38] SOUTH AFRICAN LAW COMMISSION WORKING PAPER 53 PROJECT 86 'EUTHANASIA AND THE ARTIFICIAL PRESERVATIONOF LIFE' (1994) 134 Private Defence[39] SvMOGOHLWANE1982(2)SA587(T)
7 135[40] SvKAMFFER 1965(3)SA96(T) 136[41] RvZKALALA1953(2)SA568(A) 137[42] R v K 1956 (3) SA 353 (A) 138[43] RvPATEL 1959(3)SA 121 (A) 13g[44] S v T1986 (2) SA 112 (O)
8 140[45] RvJACKBOB 1929 SWA32 145[46] RvSTEPHEN 1928 WLD 170 145 Contents ix[47] RvSCHULTZ1942 OPD56 147[48] SvMOGOHLWANE1982(2)SA587(T) 14g[49] EX PARTE MINISTER VAN JUSTISIE.
9 IN RE S v VAN WYK 1967 (1) SA488 (A) 151[50] SvNGOMANE1979(3)SA859(A) 162 Necessity[51] S v BAILEY 1982 (3) SA 772 (A) 163[52] RvCANESTRA1951(2)SA317(A) 165[53] SvPRETORIUS 1975(2)SA85(SWA) 166[54] Sv ADAMS; Sv WERNER 1981 (l)SA 187 (A) 168[55] Rv MAHOMED 1938 AD 30 170[56] SvPETERSON 1980(USA938(A) 171[57] TH)
