Effect of Hyperloop Technologies on Electric Grid ... - Energy

1 Effect of Hyperloop Technologies on the Electric Grid and Transportation Energy January 2021 United States Department of Energy Washington, DC 20585 Department of Energy |January 2021 Disclaimer This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United States government. Neither the United States government nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United States government or any agency thereof. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States government or any agency of Energy |January 2021 Effect of Hyperloop Technologies on Electric Grid and Transportation Energy | Page i [ This page is intentionally left blank] Department of Energy |January 2021 Effect of Hyperloop Technologies on Electric Grid and Transportation Energy | Page ii Executive Summary Hyperloop technology, initially proposed in 2013 as an innovative means for intermediate-range or intercity travel, is now being developed by several companies.

2 Proponents point to potential benefits for both passenger travel and freight transport, including time-savings, convenience, quality of service and, in some cases, increased Energy efficiency. Because the system is powered by electricity, its interface with the grid may require strategies that include Energy storage. The added infrastructure, in some cases, may present opportunities for grid-wide system benefits from integrating Hyperloop systems with variable Energy resources. DOE s analysis of potential grid and Energy efficiency impacts is based on conceptual data, as drawn from open sources or made available by developers, and on transportation Energy use data. DOE relied, additionally, on studies of Hyperloop systems by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Volpe Transportation Center, and Department of Transportation. Modeling of grid impacts was carried out by DOE s Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, utilizing electrical grid representations in three areas of the United States.

3 Consistent with information found in concept papers, DOE s analysis assumed that a typical travel distance for a Hyperloop system would lie within an intercity range, that is, between 100 to 1,000 miles. Data indicate that Energy use in the intercity market represents about 30 percent of total transportation Energy use in the United States. Potential Effects on the Electric Grid DOE s modeling found that the Energy and power demands of an operational Hyperloop system would be significant. The electrical Energy required to support one moderately sized Hyperloop system over a 24-hour period might be in the range of 500 to 600 MWh/day for passenger travel; and up to 1,900 MWh/day for heavier freight. Peak power demand might be in the range of 100 to 600 MW for passenger systems and up to 2,000 MW for heavier freight systems. While the amount of Energy required would be significant, it would likely fall within the operational capacities of most power generating and transmission networks.

4 For Hyperloop systems connected directly to the grid, however, the fluctuating power dynamics could present serious challenges for grid integration. DOE modeling found that the power factor, magnitude, short duration, frequency, and number of power pulses per day, both from the grid (for pod launch and acceleration) and back to the grid (during periods of regenerative braking), would induce unusual stresses throughout the grid. These stresses, if sustained over time, would adversely impact electrical generating and transmission equipment, power quality, and long-term system maintenance and reliability, with implications for regional grid stability. Such impacts would need to be mitigated by buffering technology or by alternative designs. DOE is aware of innovative designs and Technologies that address these issues (see Section II). Department of Energy |January 2021 Effect of Hyperloop Technologies on Electric Grid and Transportation Energy | Page iii Potential Effects on Transportation Energy Demand DOE s analysis found that Hyperloop transport of passengers, in selected cases, could save Energy by up to 20 percent, compared to passenger travel by other modes, such as air or personal travel in light duty vehicles, as measured in terms of Energy used per passenger-mile, and when compared to the average fleet efficiency projected to 2030.

5 Such Energy savings would be less, if compared to today s best in class vehicles, or to a future fleet with higher vehicle utilization ( , passengers/vehicle) factors. DOE considered a hypothetical case of one 300-mile Hyperloop passenger system, carrying 15,000 passengers per day, which derived its travel demand by modal shift from a mix of air, rail , and road traffic. The annual Energy savings were estimated to be about trillion Btu in 2030, or about percent of national transportation Energy demand. The extent to which such savings might be scalable from one exemplar system to a national network, however, would depend on Hyperloop s ability to deploy widely and capture significant shares of its respective markets. DOE s analysis assumed varying levels of intercity network penetration from 1 system up to 1,0 00 systems, with hypothetical Energy savings estimates. Passenger travel in the intercity range of 100 to 1,000 miles is limited.

6 Some intercity routes exhibit high traffic volumes and others much less. Energy savings on a national scale would be expected to be proportionate to the extent of deployment, which may itself be limited by intercity travel volumes. Alternatively, if such systems were able to create significant added or induced travel demand, overall Energy system use might increase, not decrease. The analysis shows that Hyperloop transport of freight would be less Energy -efficient per ton-mile shipped than all other modes of freight transport, except for air. In the case of heavier freight transport, DOE estimates that Hyperloop systems would be at least 8 times less Energy -efficient than transport by water and rail , in terms of Energy used per ton-mile shipped; and at least 3 times less Energy -efficient than transport by truck. In the case of lighter freight, such as by air, Energy savings from modal shift would be limited by the total Energy used for air freight traveling in the intercity range, which is estimated to be less than 50 trillion BTU per year, or less than percent of national transportation Energy use.

7 Scenarios that allocate all forms of higher-value freight to Hyperloop , however, including non-air modes of shipping, such as by truck, indicate an increase in Energy use of around 1 percent of total transportation Energy demand, due to loss of Energy efficiency per-ton-mile compared to shipment by trucks. Apart from Energy , Hyperloop literature suggests that an array of potential benefits may be realized from fully operational Hyperloop systems for passenger travel and shipping of freight. These may include economic benefits, environmental factors, reduced congestion, time-savings, grid complementarities, or induced demand. This analysis focused on Energy and the grid. No overall net benefit calculation was attempted. Department of Energy |January 2021 Effect of Hyperloop Technologies on Electric Grid and Transportation Energy | Page iv Acronyms and Abbreviations BTU British Thermal Unit DOE Department of Energy EI Eastern Interconnect EIA Energy Information Administration ERCOT Electric Reliability Council of Texas G Gravitational acceleration rate ( meters/second/second) GW Gigawatt HTT Hyperloop Transportation Technologies Hz Hertz kV Kilovolt mph Miles per Hour MVA Mega volt amp MW Megawatt MWh Megawatt-hour NASA National Aeronautics and Space Administration NERC North American Electric Reliability Corporation PJM Regional transmission organization that coordinates movement of wholesale electricity in all of parts of Delaware, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, Michigan, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia and the District of Columbia pu per unit (dimensionless)

8 Quad Quadrillion (1015) Btu RMRG Rocky Mountain Reserve Group TBtu Trillion (1012) Btu STATCOM Static synchronous compensator UAE United Arab Emirates VAR Volt-ampere reactive WECC Western Electricity Coordinating Council Department of Energy |January 2021 Effect of Hyperloop Technologies on Electric Grid and Transportation Energy | Page vEFFECT OF Hyperloop Technologies ON Electric GRID AND TRANSPORTATION Energy Table of Contents Acronyms and Abbreviations .. iv of Report .. 1 is Hyperloop ? .. 1 Impact on the Electricity Grid .. 11 Impact on Transportation Energy Use .. 24 Methodology (APPENDIX) .. 36 Department of Energy |January 2021 Effect of Hyperloop Technologies on Electric Grid and Transportation Energy | Page 1 I. Purpose of Report In 2018 , motivated in part by growing interest in advanced and novel approaches to intercity transportation modes, the Department of Energy undertook a study of the Energy -related aspects of Hyperloop transportation systems.

9 Such systems are seen as having the potential to increase the Energy efficiency of the Nation s transportation system. The study was framed to: (a) model the demands on the Electric grid, and the overall Energy consumption of the transportation sector, of varying levels of network penetration of an interconnected Hyperloop system; (b) include information about how these systems could be integrated into the Electric grid; and (c) identify any technological constraints of the grid that must be addressed to allow the broad adoption of Hyperloop Technologies . This report lays out the assumptions, methodologies and quantitative results of the research, modeling and analysis and summarizes the study s major findings. II. What is Hyperloop ? The term Hyperloop is applied broadly to a category of fixed-guideway surface transportation systems that use capsules or pods that travel at high speeds (potentially nearing the speed of sound) in a sealed tube at partial or near-complete Most conceptual designs envision the use of magnetic levitation for lifting and guiding the pods and linear Electric motors for acceleration and braking.

10 Such concepts eliminate the need for rails and wheels, except near stations and stops, and minimize Energy losses due to air resistance, heat and friction. Such a Hyperloop concept is being offered as a convenient, faster and potentially more Energy -efficient means of travel or freight transport than existing modes of air, rail , or road transport. It typically focuses on connecting pairs of cities, as shown conceptually in Figure 1, but could apply to intracity movement, such as to and from a downtown location to an airport or be expanded to a regional network of transportation guideways. 1 Hyperloop Commercial Feasibility Analysis: High Level Overview, Department of Transportation, 2016, Air pressure inside the tube could be as low as 1/100th atmosphere. Figure 1. Broad Hyperloop Concept (Energetics) Department of Energy |January 2021 Effect of Hyperloop Technologies on Electric Grid and Transportation Energy | Page 2 Hyperloop History The basic concept of evacuated tube-based transportation is not new.