Transcription of F. A. Hayek - IU
1 ~\Lf():I~~LondonandNewYork( <IS 5 \Firstpublished1944byGeorgeRoutledge&Son sFirstpublishedinRoutledgeClassics2001by Routledge2 ParkSquare,MiltonPark,Abingdon,OX144RN27 0 MadisonAvenue,NewYork,NY10016 Reprinted2001,2002,2003,2004,2006 RoutledgeisanimprintoftheTaylorCJ(Franci sGroup,aninformabusiness ,Bungay,SuffolkPrintedandboundinGreatBri tainbyTJInternationalLtd,Padstow, ,mechanical,orothermeans,nowknownorherea fterinvented,includingphotocopyingandrec ording,orinanyinformationstorageorretrie valsystem.))
2 Cataloguerecordforthisbookisavailablefro mtheBritishLibraryISBN10:0-415-25543-0(h bk)ISBN10:0-415-25389-6(pbk)ISBN13:978-0 -415-25543-1(hbk)ISBN13:978-0-415-25389- 5(pbk)CONTENTSPREFACEviiIntroduction1 TheAbandonedRoad102 TheGreatUtopia243 IndividualismandCollectivism334 The"Inevitability"ofPlanning455 PlanningandDemocracy596 PlanningandtheRuleofLaw757 EconomicControlandTotalitarianism918 Who,Whom?1 ,butquiteopenlybeganasa reactionagainsttheliberalismoftheFrenchR evolution, "terminatetherevolution"bya deliberatereorganisationofTHEGREATUTOPIA 25societyonhierarchicallines,andtheimpos itionofa coercive"spiritualpower".
3 Wherefreedomwasconcerned, ,andthefirstofmodernplanners,Saint-Simon ,evenpre-dictedthatthosewhodidnotobeyhis proposedplanningboardswouldbe"treatedasc attle". "demo-craticsocialism"a :Democracyextendsthesphereofindividualfr eedom[hesaidin1848], ;socialismmakeseachmana mereagent, :whiledemocracyseeksequalityinliberty,so cialismseeksequalityinrestraintandservit ude.'Toallaythesesuspicionsandtoharnesst oitscartthestrongestofallpoliticalmotive s,thecravingforfreedom,socialismbeganinc reasinglytomakeuseofthepromiseofa"newfre edom".
4 "economicfreedom",withoutwhichthepolitic alfreedomalreadygainedwas"notworthhaving ".OnlysocialismwascapableofeffectingI"Di scoursprononceaI'assembleeconstituanteIe 12 Septembre1848surIaquestiondudroitautrava il."CEuvrescompletesd'AlexisdeTocquevi11 ~ ,1866, ,freedomfromthearbi-trarypowerofothermen ,releasefromthetieswhichlefttheindividua lnochoicebutobediencetotheordersofa ,however,wastobefreedomfromnecessity,rel easefromthecompulsionofthecircumstancesw hichinevitablylimittherangeofchoiceofall ofus, ,the"despotismofphysicalwant"hadtobebrok en,the"restraintsoftheeconomicsystem" ,ofcourse,merelyanothernameforpower!
5 ,althoughthepromisesofthisnewfree-domwer eoftencoupledwithirresponsiblepromisesof a greatincreaseinmaterialwealthina socialistsociety,it ,whichweshallmeetagainandagainthroughout thisdiscussion,istoobiga ,itissocloselyalliedwithitthatalmostseve ntyyearsagoa Frenchscholar,discussingitsSaint-Simonia norigins,wasledtosaythatthistheoryoflibe rty"estaelleseuletoutIesocial-isme"CPoJa net,Saint-SimonetIeSaint-Simonisme,1878, ,note).Themostexplicitdefenderofthisconf usionis,significantly,theleadingphilosop herofAmericanleft-wingism,JohnDewey,acco rdingtowhom"libertyistheeffect-ivepowert odospecificthings"sothat"thedemandforlib ertyisdemandforpower"("LibertyandSocialC ontrol",TheSocialFrontier,November19 35, ).
6 Differentsensebythetwogroups, ,forblindingthemtotheconflictwhichexists betweenthebasicprinciplesofsocialismandl iberalism, :thereforeitisnotsurprisingthattothemthe ideashouldappearinconceivableofsocialism leadingtotheoppositeofliberty.**Inrecent years,however, ,inspiteofthecontraryexpectationwithwhic hheapproachedhissubject,hasbeenimpressed withtheextraordin-arysimilarityinmanyres pectsoftheconditionsunder"fas-cism"and"c ommunism".While"progressives"inthiscount ryandelsewherewerestilldeludingthemselve sthatcommunismandfascismrepresentedoppos itepoles, ,Lenin'soldfriend,whofoundhimselfcompell edtoadmitthat"insteadofbeingbetter,Stali nismisworsethanfascism,moreruthless,barb arous,unjust,immoral,anti-democratic,unr edeemedbyanyhopeorscruple",andthatitis"b etterdescribedassuperfascist".
7 Andwhenwefindthesameauthorrecognisingtha t"Stalinismissocialism,inthesenseofbeing aninevitablealthoughunforeseenpoliticala ccompani-mentofthenationalisationandcoll ectivisationwhichhehadrelieduponaspartof hisplanforerectinga classlesssociety", 'scaseis perhapsthemostremarkable, ,whointwelveyearsinRussiaasanAmer-icanco rrespondenthadseenallhisidealsshattered, summeduptheconclusionsofhisstudiestherea ndinGermanyandItalyinthestatementthat"So cialismiscertaintoprove,inthebegin-ninga tleast,theroadNOTtofreedom,buttodictator shipandcounter-dictatorships, meansseemsdefinitelytobelongtotheworldof utopias.
8 "2 Similarlya Britishwriter, ,aftermanyyearsofcloseobservationofdevel op-mentsinEuropeasa foreigncorrespondent,concludesthat"Marxi smhasledtoFascismandNational-Socialism,b ecause,inallessentials,itisFascismandNat ionalSocialism". ,Stalin'sRussiaandtheCrisisofSocialism,1 940, ,AFalseUtopia,1937, ,UntoCcesar,1939, moreabundantlife,theymustin practicerenounceit;astheorganiseddirecti onincreases, positiontojudgemightbeselectedfrompublic ationsofrecentyears, [ ]hasforcedRussiatotravelthesameroadtowar dsatotalitarian,purelynegative, thestagereachedaftercommunismhasprovedan illusion, ,November1936, ,1939, (himselfanex-MarxistFascist),Sozialismus undFaszismus,Munich1925, , ,and3 ,fromMussolinidownwards(andnotexcludingL avalandQuisling)
9 , youngcommunistcouldbeconvertedintoa NaziorviceversawasgenerallyknowninGerman y, Universityteacherinthiscountryduringthe1 930shasseenEnglishandAmericanstudentsret urnfromtheContinent,uncertainwhetherthey werecommunistsorNazisandcertainonly ,ofcourse, ,therealenemy,themanwithwhomtheyhadnothi ngincommonandwhomtheycouldnothopetoconvi nce,is ,andtothecommunisttheNazi,andtoboththeso cialist,arepotentialrecruitswhoaremadeof therighttimber,althoughtheyhavelistenedt ofalseprophets, officialpropagandafromeitherside, "TheRediscoveryofLiberalism",ProfessorEd uardHeimann,oneoftheleadersofGermanrelig ioussocialism,writes:Hitlerismproclaimsi tselfasbothtruedemocracyandtruesocialism ,andtheterribletruthisthatthereis a grainoftruthforsuchclaims-aninfinitesima lgrain,tobesure,butatanyTHEGREATUTOPIA31 rateenoughtoserveasa , 'Itshouldbeaddedthatthishatredhadlittleo ccasiontoshowitselfinpracticemerelybecau se,bythetimeHitlercametopower, wassocialismthathadkilledit.
10 **Whiletomanywhohavewatchedthetransition fromsocialismtofascismatclosequartersthe connectionbetweenthetwosystemshasbecomei ncreasinglyobvious, , ,soeasilydothemostirreconcilableidealsst illlivetogether,thatwecanstillhearsuchco ntradictionsintermsas"individualistsocia lism" ,noth-ingcanbemoreurgentthanthatweshould seriouslyexaminetherealsignificanceofthe evolutionthathastakenplaceISocialResearc h(NewYork), , , ,whatevermayhavebeenhisreasons,Hitlertho ughtit expedienttodeclareinoneofhispublicspeech esaslateasFebruary1941that"basicallyNati onalSocialismandMarxismarethesame"(CfThe BulletinofInternationalNewspublishedbyth eRoyalInstituteofInternationalAffairs, , , )
