“Handed to Them on a Plate” - FrameWorks Institute

1 handed to them on a plate :A FrameWorks RESEARCH REPORTM ichael Baran, Eric Lindland, Nathaniel Kendall-Taylor and Michael KohutMapping the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human ServicesJULY 2013 Table of Introduction Summary of Findings Methods Expert Interviews Cultural Models Interviews Findings Expert Interviews Cultural Models Interviews the Gaps and Overlaps in Understanding Conclusion and Future Direction A: Research Methods B: Theoretical Foundations 43 Mapping the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services FrameWorks Institute 2013iMEDIA CONTENT ANALYSIS CULTURAL MODELSMAP THE GAPS EXPLANATORY METAPHORVALUESMESSAGE !

2 "#$%&#'($)*$+", $0#12&3#04$&0$1#. $&70$3)1#$/. #$./($7"#$#**#370$7".7$/. #$".0$)/$5,8'&3$0,55)17$*)1$.((1#00&/6$7 "#$9#:$0)3&.'$&00,#0$)*$),1$7 @ @&7"$0#2#1#$3)/0#?,#/3#0$*)1$")@ $Mapping the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services 3 FrameWorks Institute @ @ @ @&7"$#>5#17$2 the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services 4 FrameWorks Institute of FindingsThe Expert View of Human $ B, $0#12&3#0$"#'5$5#)5'#$7)$-##7$/##(0$.31) 00$7"#$' $ $$+,2%-#$%,.!-/%0$#*)'$0%)!3"#(-/(1 $ $ @$%&''$7" $+,-(%-#$%(,$%',-44$/5$0%&-'$6%72%(,$%.

3 !-/%0$#*)'$0%8)$461 Y) #/7.'& )/V$!"#$%&#'($&0$(&2&(#($&/7)$0&')0$7".7 $3)-5#7#$*)1$*,/(0$ "#1$7"./$3)''.8) #$*)1$8#77#1$),73)-#0;$Mapping the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services 5 FrameWorks Institute 2013i $)*$&/3#/7&2#$7)$&//) #V$X#3.,0#$7"#$%&#'($1#'&#0$)/$()/)10$./ ($)7"#1$*,/(&/6$) )/0$7".7$7#/($7)$8#$1& #10#C$7"#1#$&0$'&77'#$&/3#/7&2#$7)$&//) #$./($31#.7#$-)1#$#**#37&2#$51#2#/7&)/$. /($&/7#12#/7&)/$.551).3"#0;$ +,-(%-#$%(,$%($/0)"/0%9)(,)/%(,$%8)$461 W, )/$)*$.&(V$I)1$#>5#170$@ @ $!"#:$7",0$#>3',(#$6#/#1.'$0#12&3#0$'&9# $5)'&3&/6C$-#(&3.'$0#12&3#0C$5,8'&3$#(, )/$.

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

5 /($51)2&0&)/$./($&/$&70$3)--,/& )/0$@&7"$7"#$5,8'&3;$$Mapping the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services 6 FrameWorks Institute 2013iThe Public s View of Human ServicesJBH!$KM$JAZZQXAKL[\ $!"&0$&-5'&3&7$*)3,0$)/$8)/-/')-4$'#)($# )-$./($)/6$3$/6$/'$$".0$8##/$)80#12#($&/ $)7"#1$ #J)190$1#0#.13"$&/$.1#.0$0,3"$.0$#(, )/^$./($#.1':$3"&'($(#2#')5-#/7_$./($1#5 1#0#/70$.$*),/(.7&)/.'$H-#1& $3,'7,1.'$-)(#'; J"&'#$&/*) $*)3,0#($51& ':$)/$%&/./3&.'$.05#370$)*$@#''Q8#&/6C$7 "#1#$@ $$H7$7"#0#$7&-#0C$&/*) $#-5".0&G#($0)3&.'$3)//#37&)/0$.0$ $", $/##(0;$$B)@ @ @#''Q8# $ @#''Q8# $ $Mapping the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services 7 FrameWorks Institute 2013i $ @#''Q8# $JB`$WE$ME<A$]AE]ZA$WE$JAZZ$HLW$E!

6 BAaM$WEL=!\$ @ @"#/$*)13#($7)$1#05)/($7)$51)8&/6$?,#07 $ K/*) $*)3,0#($)/$(&**#1#/3#0$&/$&/(&2&(,.'$@ @ @ @ @")$()$/)7$&0$7"#$(&**#1#/3#$8#7@ @")$()$/)7;$$ J"#/$&/*) $7"),6"7$05#3&%&3.'':$.8),7$@ @#''Q8# @ @#''Q8# $Mapping the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services 8 FrameWorks Institute 2013i $=!34)'-()"/0> $ @ $ !"#$&-5'&3&7$/)7&)/$)*$3)--,/&7:$.0$.$0) ,13#$)*$(./6#1$ #0$&7$(&*%&3,'7$7)$3)--,/& #$.8),7$3)--,/&7:$.0$7"#$'#2#'$./($0&7#$ )*$0#12&3#0$7".7$&-51)2#$@#''Q8# $ @ $M,3"$/)7&)/0$.1#$"&6"':$,/51)(,37&2#$&/ $# $7"#$5,8'&3$&/$0)',7&) #($7"&/9&/6$.

7 /($3.,0#$5#)5'#$7)$(&0# #$*1)-$3)/0&(#1&/6$ :$)*$7"#$(##5$./($(&*%&3,'7$0)3&.'$&00,# 0$7".7$", $0#12&3#0$.((1#00;$Mapping the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services 9 FrameWorks Institute 2013iJBH!$HaA$+BS<HL$MAaeKYAM4$HLW$BEJ$WE$!BA`$JEaP\$ $ @#1#$)**#1#(C$(&03,00&)/0$*)3,0#($#>3',0&2#':$)/$(&1#37$0#12&3#0$51)2 $C"(%"/$%)/&"#!-/(%)/%".#%)/($#*)$90%6)0 '.00$6%-6*"'-'2%"#%3#$*$/()"/%-0%3-#(%"& %,.!-/%0$#*)'$0;$ $$$ $A> (&/6$7"#0#$,/(# (&/60$1#?,&1#0$.$@ @ $ @)19$,/(#1-&/#$5,8'&3$0,55)17$*)1$-)1#$* ,/( @/$/##(0;$B)@#2#1C$7"#1#$@ $Mapping the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services 10 FrameWorks Institute 2013i $J"&'#$7"#:$3),'($& #$.

8 $51)(,37&2#$1)'#$*)1$6)2#1/-#/7$&/$./$+& (#.'$@ $J"#/$7"#:$1#.0)/#($7"1),6"$,/(# (&/60$)*$6)2#1/-#/7$.0$&/#57$./($3)11,57 $N.$()-&/./7$H-#1& $3,'7,1.'$-)(#'$)*$6)2#1/-#/7fOC$&/*) $8# #$*.7.'&07&3$.8),7$51)05#370$7)$&-51)2#$ ", $0#12 =!34)'-()"/0>% $X:$')(6&/6$5#13#57&)/0$)*$3.,0#$%&1-':$ .7$7"#$&/(&2&(,.'$'#2#'C$7"#0#$-)(#'0$# '$071)/6$/)7&)/0$)*$)/6)*) $1#05)/0 !"#$5,8'&3=0$1#3)6/&7&)/$)*$7"#$-&00&/6$ 0,55)17&2#$*,/37&)/$)*$-)(#1/$3)--,/&7&# 0$-.:$5'.:$.$51)(,37&2#$1)'#$&/$1#* $", $0#12&3#0$./($&/2&6) $0#/0#0$)*$5,8'&3$1#05)/0 $ !"#$.55'& )/$)*$()-&/./7$H-#1& $-)(#'0$)*$6)2#1/-#/7$.0$) ,#C$3)11,57$.

9 /($&/#57$&0$"&6"':$,/51)(,37&2#$&/$7"&/9 &/6$.8),7$", $0#12&3#0$./($7"#$-# #0$7".7$#-#16#$*1)-$#>5#170$&/$7" $Mapping the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services 11 FrameWorks Institute MethodsExpert Interviews #J)190$1#0#.13"#10$3)/(,37#($.$0#1&#0$)* $U^$)/#Q)/Q)/#$7#'#5")/#$&/7#12&#@ $K/$#.3"$&/7#12&#@C$7"#$&/7#12&#@ $K/7#12&#@ Cultural Models Interviews the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services 12 FrameWorks Institute @ @ @#''Q8# $H0$7"#$6).'$)*$7"#0#$&/7#12&#@ @ @"&3"$7"#:$@#1#$3)2#1#($7)$7"#$ $H''$&/7#12&#@ @ $K/$ :$ #0C$.

10 /.':0&0$1#2#.'#($3)/%'&37&/6$-)(#'0$7".7 $5#)5'#$81),6"7$7)$8#.1$)/$7"#$ #$ @#&6"7$6&2#/$7)$7"#0#$3)/%'&37&/6$-)(#'0 ;Mapping the Gaps Between Expert and Public Understandings of Human Services 13 FrameWorks Institute InterviewsW,1&/6$),1$&/7#12&#@ $!"#0#$7"#-#0$ $8#$ #6)1&G#($.0$1#05)/(&/6$7)$%&2#$*),/(.7&) /.'$?,#07 J".7$.1#$", $0#12 J":$.1#$", $0#12&3#0$&-5) \_;J".7$.1#$7"#$3".''#/6#0$*.3#($8:$7"#$ ", $0#12 J".7$.1#$7"#$7#/0&)/0$@&7"&/$7"#$% J".7$ $8#$()/#$7)$&-51)2#$", $0#12 $JBH!$HaA$BS<HL$MAaeKYAM\ $!"#$ ),0$#>&07&/6$", $0#12&3#$) )/0$7#/($7)$05#3&.'&G#$&/$@ B, $0#12&3#0$"#'5$5#)5'#$7)$-##7$/##(0$.