INDUSTRIAL COURT JUDGMENT CATALOGUE

1 PRIMARY ISSUEDATE OF DELIVERY/ DISPUTE NUMBEROTHER ISSUES HIGHLIGHTEDAA bsenteeismFebruary 15, 2007 National Union of Government and Federated International (Caribbean) LimitedMedical certificateAbsenteeismTD 132 of 1979 Geddes Grant Sprostons Industries LimitedAll Trinidad Sugar and General Workers UnionAbsenteeismFebruary 10, 1998 Communication Workers' UnionExcellent Stores LimitedDuty to inform employer of absenceAbsenteeismTD 159 of 1974 Cannings Industries LimitedNational Union of Government and Federated WorkersDisciplinary processAbsenteeismTD 235 of 1984 Trinidad and Tobago Sanitary Plumbing Contractors LimitedNational Union of Government and Federated WorkersLeave of AbsenceAbsenteeismJanuary 12, 2000 Oilfields Workers Trade Union Petroleum Company of Trinidad and Tobago Summary DismissalAbsenteeism (poor regularity and punctualityOctober 21, 2004 National Union of Government and federated WorkersGuardia Wackenhut LimitedConstructive dismissal (defined))

2 Alcohol abuseFebruary 13, 2004 Oilfields Workers Trade Union Trinidad and Tobago Electricity CommissionApplication on re-instatement of Trade DisputeTD 40 of 1990 Communication Workers' UnionCaribbean Telecoms LimitedNot restoredApplication on re-instatement of Trade DisputeJuly 28, 2006 Seamen and Waterfront Workers Trade UnionPoint Lisas INDUSTRIAL Port Development Corporation Trade Dispute re-instatedApplication on re-instatement of Trade DisputeMay 16, 2002 National Union of Government and Federated WorkersHitlal's PrinteryNot restoredApplication on re-instatement of Trade DisputeJune 16, 1998 Seamen and Waterfront Workers Trade UnionPort Authority of Trinidad and TobagoOrder as to costs in favour of EmployerAssessment of damagesDecember 12, 2005 Estate Police Association of Trinidad and TobagoLever Brothers West Indies LimitedAssessment of damagesTD 198 of 1969 British West Indian Airways LimitedThe Superintendents AssociationAssessment of damagesJuly 31, 2001 Banking, Insurance and General Workers Union Hindu Credit Union Cooperative Society LimitedLoss of confidenceKEY: TD -Trade Dispute; IRO - INDUSTRIAL Relations Offence; ST - Special Tribunal; ESD - Essential Services Division; A - Application; RSBD - Retrenchment and Severance Dispute; OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Complaint.

3 C - COURT JUDGMENT CATALOGUEPARTIESPRIMARY ISSUEDATE OF DELIVERY/ DISPUTE NUMBEROTHER ISSUES HIGHLIGHTEDPARTIESA ttorney filing on behalf of Client - IRO October 26, 1978 British West Indian Airways LimitedTrinidad and Tobago Airline Pilots AssociationBBreach of Collective AgreementNovember 8, 2001 Public Services AssociationWater and Sewerage AuthorityDisciplinary procedureBreach of Contract January 18, 2012 Ricardo Welch( ) Trinibashment LimitedMeasure of Damages for wrongful dismissal Breach of Contract July 26, 1909 Addis Gramophone Company LimitedWrongful dismissalBreach of Operational Procedure - DismissalJune 16, 1998 Seamen and Waterfront Workers Trade UnionPort Authority of Trinidad and TobagoApplication for Reinstatement of Trade DisputeBurden of ProofJuly 10, 2006 Banking, Insurance and General Workers Union Nicholas Development LimitedRedundancyCCollective AgreementJuly 31, 2009 Steel Workers Union of Trinidad and TobagoCaribbean Ispat LimitedBargaining UnitCollective AgreementJanuary 14, 2005 Managers and Supervisors Association of Trinidad and TobagoMetal Industries LimitedCompetency of IR practitionersCollective AgreementApril 13, 1984 Sterling Drugs International LimitedThe Union of Foods.

4 Hotels and INDUSTRIAL WorkersBreakdown in negotiationsCollective AgreementApril 17, 1985 Ferreira Optical Limited Transport and INDUSTRIAL Workers UnionCompensation for serviceCollective AgreementTD 225 of 2007 Oilfields Workers' Trade UnionRobinson Crusoe Beach Resort Collective AgreementFebruary 18, 2004 Communication Workers' Union Hilton Trinidad and Conference CentreBreakdown in negotiationsCollective Bargaining - "Good faith"IRO 16 of 1996 National Petroleum Staff Association Petroleum Company of Trinidad and Tobago Exclusion from the bargaining unitConflict of InterestFebruary 8, 2008 Banking Insurance and General Workers UnionFirst Citizens Bank LimitedConflict of InterestTD 23 of 1986 Sugar Industry Staff Association Caroni [1975] LimitedConflict of InterestDecember 15, 1988 Public Services Association of Trinidad and TobagoNational Insurance Property Development Company LimitedConflict of InterestMarch 8, 1990 Communication Workers' UnionHoliday Inn Trinidad LtdConstructive DismissalTD 108 of 2009 National Union of Domestic EmployeesCourts (Trinidad) LimitedVoluntary resignationConstructive DismissalTD 12 of 1991 Oilfields Workers Trade Union Alston's Building Enterprises LimitedConstructive DismissalMay 18, 2006 Banking, Insurance and General Workers Union St.

5 Clair Insurance Services Company LimitedJob transferPRIMARY ISSUEDATE OF DELIVERY/ DISPUTE NUMBEROTHER ISSUES HIGHLIGHTEDPARTIESC onstructive DismissalTD 197 of 2002 Oilfields Workers Trade Union Schlumberger (Trinidad) IncorporatedRedundancy Constructive DismissalJune 27, 2012 Banking, Insurance and General Workers Union Original Foods LimitedUnilateral reduction of worker's salary/ rate of pay in contractConstructive DismissalSeptember 21, 2005 Seamen and Waterfront Workers Trade UnionPoint Lisas INDUSTRIAL Port Development Corporation Safety in the WorkplaceConstructive DismissalTD 274 of 1984 Managers and Supervisors Association of Trinidad and TobagoFurness and Gordon LimitedConstructive DismissalTD 28 of 1988 Union of Commercial & INDUSTRIAL WorkersHoliday Inn Trinidad LtdConstructive DismissalTD 37 of 1988 Managers and Supervisors Association of Trinidad and TobagoBilmor LimitedConstructive DismissalJuly 7.

6 1978 Neal & Massy Holdings LtdNational Workers Trade UnionConstructive DismissalTD 5 of 1995 Bank and Employees' Union Republic Bank LimitedNature of Constructive Dismissal Constructive DismissalApril 5, 1993 National Union of Government and Federated WorkersFurness Trinidad LimitedDemotionConstructive DismissalTD 63 of 1989 Managers and Supervisors Association of Trinidad and Hodgkinson LimitedCost of Living Allowance (COLA)TD 82 and 84 of 1992 Oilfields Workers' Trade UnionTrinidad Cement LimitedDDisciplinary processFebruary 11, 2008 Oilfields Workers Trade Union Trinidad and Tobago Electricity CommissionDue processDismissal - COURT 's decision to interfere with employer's decisionJanuary 23, 1996 Bank and General Workers' UnionTrinidad Express Newspaper LimitedJurisdictionDismissal - Fighting on the jobJuly 21, 1983 Well Services LimitedOilfields Workers' Trade UnionDismissal - Fighting on the jobMay 24, 1995 The National General Workers' Union Consolidated Biscuit (Trinidad)

7 LimitedDismissal - Fighting on the jobTD 99 of 2007 National Union of Government and Federated WorkersPizza Boys Group of CompaniesJudgment based on Witness Statements Dismissal - Harsh, Oppressive and Contrary to good IR principlesESD 46 of 1998 Trinidad and Tobago Airline Pilots Association Air Caribbean LimitedPRIMARY ISSUEDATE OF DELIVERY/ DISPUTE NUMBEROTHER ISSUES HIGHLIGHTEDPARTIESD ismissal - Harsh, Oppressive and Contrary to good IR principlesNovember 14, 1980 Trinidad and Tobago Television Company LimitedCommunication, Transport and General Workers' Trade UnionCollective Agreement cannot supersede the Act/ Interpretation of Collective AgreementDismissal - MisconductJune 18, 1974 Electrical Industries and INDUSTRIAL Workers UnionEmployees' duty to employerEEmployment ContractJanuary 26, 2012 Banking Insurance and General Workers UnionChief Personnel Officer & Ministry of Science, Technology and Tertiary EducationCPO is the EmployerExemplary DamagesOctober 22, 2012 Communication Workers' Union The Sport Company of Trinidad and Tobago Payment for unexpired period of contractFFailure to meet and enter into negotiationsFebruary 15, 2007 Communication Workers UnionHilton International (Trinidad)

8 & othersFailure to meet and enter into negotiationsIRO 29 of 1988 Oilfields Workers' Trade UnionLever Brothers West Indies LimitedGrievance procedureFailure to meet and treatApril 5, 2001 Oilfields Workers Trade Union Nestle Trinidad and Tobago LimitedFailure to meet and treat - IRON ovember 5, 1999 National Union of Government and federated WorkersChief Personnel OfficerChange of financial yearFailure to meet and treat - IROJ anuary 25, 2013 National Union of Government and Federated WorkersMr. Roger Mew - CEO; Carib Glassworks Limited; and Mr. Ancil Rampersad - Senior HROC ompany official fined Fixed Term ContractFebruary 28, 2005 National Union of Government and Federated WorkersTobago House of AssemblyReason for termination FraudMarch 28, 1994 All Trinidad Sugar and General Workers Trade UnionCaroni (1975) LimitedNon-observance of Company procedureFreedom of Information ActApril 2, 2007 Ashford SankarPublic Service CommissionFreelancersTD 39 of 2002 Banking, Insurance and General Workers Union Daily News LimitedBreakdown in negotiationsGGrievance procedureJuly 29, 1991 Oilfields Workers' Trade UnionLever Brothers West Indies LimitedHPRIMARY ISSUEDATE OF DELIVERY/ DISPUTE NUMBEROTHER ISSUES HIGHLIGHTEDPARTIESII llegal Substances/ under the influence of an intoxicantTD 90 of 1995 All Trinidad Sugar and General Workers UnionSeereeram Brothers LimitedEmployer's Obligation to rehabilitate the workerIllegal Substances/ under the influence of an intoxicantNovember 20, 2012 Communication Workers' UnionRotoplastics Trinidad LimitedNo case submissionIndependent ContractorJanuary 28, 1994 Communication Workers UnionBesplate Trinidad LimitedContract of Service vs.

9 Contract for serviceIndependent ContractorTD 47 of 1994 Contractors and General Workers UnionLake Asphalt of Trinidad and Tobago (1978) LimitedContract of Service vs. Contract for serviceIndependent Contractor (Contract of OR Contract for services)March 25, 2004 Banking Insurance and General Workers UnionAir CanadaIndustrial COURT JurisdictionIndustrial Action not in keeping with good INDUSTRIAL relationsMarch 11, 1983 Allied Innkeepers of Trinidad and TobagoCommunication Workers' UnionIndustrial Action not in keeping with good INDUSTRIAL relationsSeptember 13, 1974 Trinidad and Tobago Meat Processors LimitedUnion of Food, Hotels, and INDUSTRIAL WorkersInsubordinationJuly 27, 2005 National Union of Government and federated WorkersJusamco Pavers LimitedNatural Justice - Witness cannot act as judge in a hearingInsubordination - GrossApril 12, 1991 Secondary Schools Maintenance Training and Security Company LimitedTransport and INDUSTRIAL Workers UnionDismissalInsubordination - GrossSeptember 10, 1999 Tobago Hospitality Trade Union Mount Irvine Bay Hotel Use of obscene language JJob AbandonmentOctober 26.

10 2006 Communication Workers UnionDaco Printing Services LimitedJob AbandonmentMarch 1, 2006 Oilfields Workers Trade Union Auto Care Enterprises LimitedNo case submissionJob AbandonmentJune 2, 2011 Communication Workers' UnionFair Chance Racing ServiceJob AbandonmentFebruary 2, 2007 Communication Workers UnionWaste Disposal LimitedBalance of proofJob abandonment TD 13 of 1974 Dunlop Trinidad LimitedOilfields Workers' Trade UnionJob abandonment November 23, 2011 National Union of Domestic EmployeesCaribbean Paper and Printed Products 1993 LimitedWorker terminated the employment relationshipJob Abandonment January 24, 2008 Oilfields Workers' Trade UnionSunshine Enterprises LimitedAmending Evidence and ArgumentsJob Abandonment - dismissalMay 26, 2011 Communication Workers' Union Servisair Trinidad and Tobago LimitedCompany dismissed the workerPRIMARY ISSUEDATE OF DELIVERY/ DISPUTE NUMBEROTHER ISSUES HIGHLIGHTEDPARTIESJ urisdiction of the courtIRO 44 and 45 of 1989 Transport and INDUSTRIAL Workers' Union Secondary Schools Maintenance Training and Security Company LimitedUnregistered Collective Agreement is of no effect Jurisdiction of the courtJanuary 17, 2005 Union of Commercial & INDUSTRIAL WorkersPort Authority of Trinidad and TobagoWorker under the meaning of the actJurisdiction of the courtMay 12, 2011 National Workers UnionPremier Bridal Company LimitedCourt unable to go beyond unresolved certificateJurisdiction of the courtTD A1 of 1999 Association of Technical Administrative and Supervisory StaffCaroni (1975)