INTERPRETATION AND APPLICATION OF ARTICLE …

1 ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT INTERPRETATION AND APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 5 (PERMANENT establishment ) OF THE OECD MODEL TAX CONVENTION 12 October 2011 to 10 February 2012 CENTRE FOR TAX POLICY AND ADMINISTRATION 2 12 October 2011 INTERPRETATION AND APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 5 (PERMANENT establishment ) OF THE OECD MODEL TAX CONVENTION Public discussion draft ARTICLE 5 (Permanent establishment ) of the OECD Model Tax Convention includes the definition of the treaty concept of permanent establishment , which is primarily used for the purpose of the allocation of taxing rights when an enterprise of one State derives business profits from another State.

2 Despite the long history of the concept of permanent establishment , its practical APPLICATION raises a number of issues. The Committee on Fiscal Affairs, through a subgroup of its Working Party 1 on Tax Conventions and Related Questions, has examined various questions related to the INTERPRETATION and APPLICATION of the definition of permanent establishment . This public discussion draft includes proposals for additions and changes to the Commentary on the OECD Model Tax Convention resulting from the work of that subgroup that have recently been presented to the Working Party for discussion.

3 Given the practical importance of these proposals, the Committee has decided to invite public comments on the proposed changes to the Commentary before they are thoroughly discussed by the Working Party. The proposed changes appear in the order of the paragraphs of the current Commentary on ARTICLE 5 to which they relate. The Annex includes a consolidated version of paragraphs 1 to 35 of the Commentary on ARTICLE 5 that includes all the proposed changes. The Committee intends to ask the Working Party to examine these proposed additions and changes to the OECD Model Tax Convention for possible inclusion through the next update, which is currently scheduled for 2014.

4 It therefore invites interested parties to send their comments on this discussion draft before 10 February 2012. These comments will be examined at the next meeting of the Working Party. Comments on this discussion draft should be sent electronically (in Word format) to: Grace Perez-Navarro Deputy Director, CTPA OECD 2, rue Andr Pascal 75775 Paris FRANCE e-mail: Unless otherwise requested at the time of submission, comments submitted to the OECD in response to this invitation will be posted on the OECD website. This document is a discussion draft released for the purpose of inviting comments from interested parties on the proposals prepared by a working group.

5 It reflects the majority views in the group on some issues on which there was no consensus. Given the preliminary nature of the proposals, this document does not necessarily reflect the final views of the OECD and its member countries. 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION .. 6 1. Can a farm be a permanent establishment ? (proposed paragraph of the Commentary) .. 7 Description of the issue .. 7 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 7 Background .. 7 2. Meaning of at the disposal of (paragraph of the Commentary) .. 8 Description of the issue .. 8 Recommendation of the Working Group.

6 9 Background .. 10 3. Can the premises of a (converted) local entity constitute a permanent establishment of a foreign enterprise under paragraph 1? (paragraph of the Commentary) .. 11 Description of the issue .. 11 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 11 Background .. 11 4. Home office as a PE (proposed new paragraphs and ) .. 12 Description of the issue .. 12 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 12 Background .. 13 5. Shops on ships operated in international traffic (proposed paragraph of the Commentary) .. 14 Description of the issue .. 14 Recommendation of the Working Group.

7 14 Background .. 14 6. Time requirement for the existence of a permanent establishment (paragraph 6 of the Commentary) .. 14 Description of the issue .. 14 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 16 Background .. 17 7. Presence of foreign enterprise s personnel in the host country (paragraphs 10 of the Commentary) .. 18 Description of the issue .. 18 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 18 Background .. 19 8. Main contractor who subcontracts all aspects of a contract (paragraphs 10 and 19 of the Commentary) .. 20 Description of the issue .. 20 Recommendation of the Working Group.

8 21 Background .. 21 9. APPLICATION of paragraph 3 to joint venture and partnership activities (paragraphs 10 and 19 of the Commentary) .. 22 Description of the issue .. 22 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 22 Background .. 23 4 10. Meaning of place of management (paragraph 12 of the Commentary) .. 24 Description of the issue .. 24 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 24 Background .. 25 11. Additional work on a construction site (proposed new paragraph of the Commentary) .. 25 Description of the issue .. 25 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 26 Background .. 26 12. Must the activities referred to in paragraph 4 be of a preparatory or auxiliary nature?

9 (paragraphs 21 and 23 of the Commentary) .. 26 Description of the issue .. 26 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 27 Background .. 28 13. Relationship between delivery and the sale of goods in subparagraph 4 a) (paragraphs 22 and of the Commentary) .. 28 Description of the issue .. 28 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 28 Background .. 29 14. Does a development property constitute a PE? (paragraph 22 of the Commentary) .. 30 Description of the issue .. 30 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 30 Background .. 30 15. Do goods or merchandise cover digital products or data?

10 (paragraph 22 of the Commentary) .. 31 Description of the issue .. 31 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 31 Background .. 31 16. Carrying on various activities listed alternatively in subparagraphs 4 a) and b) (paragraph 22 of the Commentary) .. 32 Description of the issue .. 32 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 32 Background .. 32 17. Negotiation of import contracts as an activity of a preparatory or auxiliary activity (paragraphs 24 and 25 of the Commentary) .. 33 Description of the issue .. 33 Recommendation of the Working Group .. 33 Background .. 34 18. Fragmentation of activities (paragraphs of the Commentary).