MAHARASHTRA POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …

1 8th CAC meeting of 2017-2018 (Book-let no 13 of Consent to operate cases) dated Page 1 of 33 MAHARASHTRA POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD Minutes of 8th Consent Appraisal Committee Meeting of 2017-2018 held on at at MHADA Office, Grihanirman Bhavan, Kalanagar, Bandra (East), Mumbai, MAHARASHTRA 400051.. The Consent Appraisal Committee meeting of the BOARD was held on Following members of the Consent Appraisal Committee were present: 1. Shri Milind Mhaiskar, Chairman Vice President & CEO, MHADA and Chairperson, MPCB, Mumbai. 2. Shri. P. Anbalagan Member Member Secretary, MPC BOARD , Mumbai 3. Shri. Padmakar Nandusekar Member Technical Advisor (Environment), MIDC, Mumbai 4. Shri. P. K. Mirashe Member Conveyor Assistant Secretary (Technical), MPC BOARD , Mumbai Additional Chief Secretary, Home (Transport) Dept.

2 , Mumbai could not attend the meeting. Leave of absence was granted to them. Following Officer of MPCB were present for the meeting: 1. Shri. V. M. Motghare, JD(APC), MPCB, Special Invitee 2. Shri. Y. B. Sontakke, JD(WPC), MPCB, Special Invitee 3. Shri A. R. Supate, PSO, Mumbai, Special Invitee 4. Shri. N. N. Gurav, Regional Officer (HQ), Mumbai, Special Invitee Chairman of the committee welcomed the members of the committee and allowed proceeding of the meeting to start. The minutes of 7thConsent Appraisal Committee meeting held on for 1st consent to operate and consent to establish (booklet no 10, 11) respectively and held on for renewal of consent (booklet no 12) circulated vide letter no. dtd. were confirmed. 8th CAC meeting of 2017-2018 (Book-let no 13 of Consent to operate cases) dated Page 2 of 33 The meeting thereafter deliberated on the fresh agenda items of 1st consent to operate [Book-let no 13] is placed before the committee and following decisions were taken.

3 Sr. No. Application unique number Name of Industry Decision on grant of consent Consent granted up to Remarks/Discussion (1) Book-let No. 13 Consent to 1st Operate 1. MPCB-CONSENT-0000003099 Western Coal Field Limited, WCL, Kamptee Deep Project Near Kandri Gram Pancjayat, Tal. Parseoni, Dist. Nagpur APPROVED 1st consent to Operate for MTPA with increased mining area existing MTPA + expansion MTPA = total 2 MTPA) Committee noted that renewal of consent to operate of existing Coal MMTPA over a mining lease area of Ha. was approved in the CAC meeting dated However, Consent was not issued due to non-submission of consent fees. Committee also noted that industry has obtained Consent to establish vide consent dated for coal mining activity of Underground mining over an mining lease area of ha for Coal Production- MTPA which was expired on Further, also noted the reply of PP that EC validity period shall be counted from the date of issuance of EC after It is further noted that PP has provided Sedimentation Tanks of size 45 X 25 X 10 mtrs and 40 X 10 X 1 mtrs, Details of Air POLLUTION CONTROL arrangement is provided.

4 As decided in earlier CAC meeting, hearing to the WCL authority was extended on They have also made the presentation about compliance made before CAC and based on the presentation made by WCL authority they have agreed to comply the consent conditions in time bound manner. In view of above, It was decided to grant 1st Operate for expansion with mining area for Coal production MTPA on a mining area of Ha. and its amalgamation with existing consent of MTPA approved in earlier CAC by imposing following 8th CAC meeting of 2017-2018 (Book-let no 13 of Consent to operate cases) dated Page 3 of 33 Sr. No. Application unique number Name of Industry Decision on grant of consent Consent granted up to Remarks/Discussion (1) conditions :- 1. PP shall provide dry deshelling / manual picking of stray material arrangement by 31st August 2018 also submit a plan for installation of Coal washery within a month.

5 2. PP shall install CAAQMS arrangement by 31st May 2018. 3. PP shall install STP within 03 months period. 4. PP shall convert existing water sprinkling arrangement into chemical fogging arrangement (MgCl2) within 03 months period. 5. PP shall submit Bank Guarantee as per BG regime within 15 days period. 6. PP shall install real-time coal ash analyser on pilot basis by 31st May 2018. 7. PP shall provide tar road in remaining area by 31st March 2018. 8. PP shall carry out over burden dump management as per CPCB guidelines. 9. PP shall carry out plantation as per EC condition before ensuing monsoon. 10. PP shall provide treatment plant for mine water discharge and submit sedimentation tank design details. 11. PP shall obtain NOC/clarification from CGWA within 03 months. Consent shall be issued after verification of consent fees payment, after receipt of latest compliance report from SRO and forfeiture of proportionate BG.

6 2. MPCB-CONSENT-0000007229 Asian Institute of Medical Sciences Pvt. Ltd. Plot No. P-72, , Milap Nagar, Dombivli (E), Kalyan NOT APPROVED Consent to Operate for Health Care Establishment -- The committee noted that the PP has already obtained CCA for 100 bedded hospital which is valid. Also noted that PP has applied for combined consent and BMW Authorization for 250 bedded hospital vide UAN Number 0000011968 & 0000007229. Also noted the request of PP for returning of both the applications as BNH registration of hospital for 250 beds was considering their future expansion. 8th CAC meeting of 2017-2018 (Book-let no 13 of Consent to operate cases) dated Page 4 of 33 Sr. No. Application unique number Name of Industry Decision on grant of consent Consent granted up to Remarks/Discussion (1) In view of above, it was decided to return both the applications bearing UAN Nos.

7 0000011968, 000007229. With condition that PP shall not carry out any expansion activity without prior permission of the BOARD . 3. MPCB-CONSENT-0000013991 JSW Dharamtar Port Pvt. Ltd., Waterfront Dharamtar, Pen, Dist. Raigad NOT APPROVED 1st Consent to Operate (Part) --- The committee noted that earlier the case was placed before CAC meeting held on The case is again resubmitted for seeking approval for part operate for expansion and renewal. Committee deliberated the issue in depth and made the following observations; 1. PP has applied for plain renewal of consent (Jetty length of mtrs) for handling capacity 13,50,000 MT/M. ( MTPA) . 2. PP has applied for first C to O for expansion for length 395 mtrs with proportionate handling capacity of 8,40,000 MT/M. ( MTPA) (total length mtrs including existing Jetty length and first phase expansion) for which C to E and EC including CRZ Clearance already obtained.

8 3. The MoEF and CC has also accorded EC for Jetty expansion project with length 1750 mtrs on 4. It is also noted from SRO remark that the work of expansion for first phase of Jetty is already completed and is ready to operate. 4. Committee also noted the reply received from MMB, GoM that JSW Dharamtar Port had carried out repairs of the Dilapidated Jetty structure of the Jetty and integrated adjacent test pile which was essential to prevent falling of debris in navigation channel and also to avoid any eventualities of accident. They have also stated that the cargo handling operation is carried out by the company from designated part of Jetty and restored part of the Jetty is not use for operation. 5. Committee also noted the PP s say that there is no 8th CAC meeting of 2017-2018 (Book-let no 13 of Consent to operate cases) dated Page 5 of 33 Sr.

9 No. Application unique number Name of Industry Decision on grant of consent Consent granted up to Remarks/Discussion (1) court matter pending against Dharamtar port in NGT & High Court. 6. The Committee noted that the reply towards opinion sort from MoEF, Govt. of India is not received till date. 7. Reminder letter to MoEF and to Env. Dep. GoM dated has been sent. Reply still awaited. In view of above, it was decided to keep the case in abeyance for 1st Operate (Part) for expansion and renewal of consent to operate till obtaining clarification from Environment Department, Govt. of MAHARASHTRA and revert back to CAC. 4. MPCB-CONSENT-0000014149 Pegasus Properties Pvt. Ltd. R-1/1, R-1/2, R-1/3, R-1/4, Rajiv Gandhi Infotech Park-III, Village- Man & Bhoir Wadi Mulshi, Dist. Pune. APPROVED 1st Consent to Operate (Part) Committee noted that PP has obtained Environmental Clearance from SEAC committee vide letter dated for total plot area 5,60,000 Sq.

10 Mtrs. and total BUA 12,13,345 Sq. Mtrs. Committee also noted that PP has obtained consent to establish dated for total plot area 5,60,000 Sq. Mtrs. and total construction BUA 6,72, Sq. Mtrs. PP has also obtained 1st consent to operate (Part-I) for total construction BUA 4,21,009 Sq. Mtrs. In view of above, it was decided to grant 1st Consent to Operate (Part -II) for Residential cum Commercial Project of M/s. Pegasus Properties Pvt. Ltd,R-1/1, R-1/2, R-1/3, R-1/4 Rajiv Gandhi Infotech Park-III, Village- Man & Bhoir Wadi Mulshi on total plot area 5,60,000 sqm and Construction BUA of 6,14, (out of TCBUA of 6,72, as per CtoE dated ) by imposing following conditions: 1. PP shall submit affidavit in BOARD prescribed format within 15 days regarding compliance of conditions of Environmental Clearance (EC) and Consent to Establish. 8th CAC meeting of 2017-2018 (Book-let no 13 of Consent to operate cases) dated Page 6 of 33 Sr.