Silicon Valley Competitiveness and Innovation Project ...

1 Silicon Valley Competitiveness and Innovation Project - 2017 ReportA Dashboard and Policy Scorecard for a Shared Agenda of Prosperity and the SVCIP partnersThe Silicon Valley Leadership Group, founded in 1978 by David Packard of Hewlett-Packard, represents nearly 400 of Silicon Valley 's most respected employers on issues, programs and campaigns that affect the economic health and quality of life in Silicon Valley . The Leadership Group focuses on key issues of importance including energy, transportation, education, housing, health care, taxation, economic vitality and the environment. Leadership Group members collectively provide nearly one of every three private sector jobs in Silicon Valley and have more than $3 trillion in annual Valley Community Foundation advances innovative philanthropic solutions to challenging problems. As the largest community foundation in the world, we engage donors and corporations from Silicon Valley , across the country and around the globe to make our region and world better for all.

2 Our passion for helping people and organizations achieve their philanthropic dreams has created a global philanthropic enterprise committed to the belief that possibilities start here. Past and Present AdvisorsGreg BeckerSilicon Valley Bank Advisory Group ChairShellye Archambeau AgarwalNortheastern University - Silicon ValleyBrian BrennanSilicon Valley Leadership GroupNeil ChaseBay Area News GroupLisa DowneyMorgan Family FoundationRosanne FoustSan Mateo County Economic Development AssociationTom FrielSilicon Valley Community Foundation Board MemberRemy GoldsmithSilicon Valley Community FoundationJosh Green Mohr Davidow VenturesCarl GuardinoSilicon Valley Leadership GroupMarci Harris POPVOX Andrew LeeEsperMayor Sam LiccardoCity of San Jos Mike Malone AuthorThomas Mohr San Mateo County Community College DistrictJonathan NelsonHackers & FoundersEduardo Rallo Pacific Community VenturesBrian Simmons San Mateo County Office of EducationKim WaleshSan Jos Dept of Economic DevelopmentErica WoodSilicon Valley Community FoundationReport Developed and Prepared byCollaborative Economics (COECON)

3 Is a strategic advisory and consulting firm that works with clients to create breakthrough solutions for regions and communities. COECON has extensive experience helping states and regions develop Innovation strategies. Principal Researchers and AuthorsJohn Melville, CEOJ anine Kaiser, Senior ConsultantElizabeth Brown, Senior ConsultantReport design by Audra Keefe, Orange Bike Design23 Dear Friends, Silicon Valley s success as the world s leading Innovation region did not occur by accident. Nor will it continue much less grow without deliberate and thoughtful actions that promote Innovation and opportunities for our employers, employees and our communities. Responding to this challenge, the Silicon Valley Leadership Group and Silicon Valley Community Foundation joined together three years ago to create the Silicon Valley Competitiveness and Innovation Project (SVCIP), a multi-year effort to assess the region s economic health and advance a shared policy agenda so that our Innovation advantage remains strong and all residents can share in our success.

4 The 2017 report shows strong job growth and economic output that exceed those of other Innovation regions. Silicon Valley continues to attract people from around the world: 2,000 people move here each month. However, warning signs indicate that our continued success is not a given. Venture capital investments have fallen for the first time in several years. Housing costs and commute times are among the highest in the nation. And gaps in educational achievement persist, resulting in fewer students graduating with the knowledge and skills they need to participate in our Innovation economy. As we enter a period of uncertainty with the new federal administration, it is critical that we join together to ensure that our region s continuing success is not left up to chance. This will require intentional public policy action at the federal, state and local levels. We are proud of several local tax measures approved by voters last November that will bring increased public funding for transportation improvements, affordable housing and other community services to enhance the region s quality of life.

5 But as this report s data tell us, there is much more to be done. Now more than ever, we must work together to ensure that Silicon Valley s economic engine remains strong, recognizing the vital role it plays in driving growth and Competitiveness . We invite you to visit our website at for important updates on our data and progress. Sincerely,A Letter from the SVCIP PartnersCarl GuardinoPresident and CEOS ilicon Valley Leadership GroupEmmett D. Carson, and PresidentSilicon Valley Community FoundationFebruary 20174 Strong and Gaining GroundNeeds attention, losing ground to other regionsCritical need for attention, and/or trending downChange from SVCIP 2016 Innovation ASSETST alentSTEM Talent Pool Change in Educational Attainment STEM Degrees Conferred International Talent Talent Migration New Entrepreneurs Risk Capitaland R&DVenture Capital Very Early Stage Funding Universities R&D Expenditures Innovation PROCESSESIdea GenerationPatents CommercializationFollow-On Investment by Stage Business InnovationCompany Pre-Exit Valuations Initial Public Offerings Mergers and Acquisitions OUTCOMES & PROSPERITYB usiness CompetitivenessLabor Productivity Output in Innovation Industries Quality of LifeHome and Rent Values Traffic Congestion Access to OpportunityPreschool Enrollment 3rd Grade English and 8th Grade Math Proficiency 11th Grade English and Mathematics Proficiency JobsJobs in Innovation Industries SVCIP Indicator Dashboard2017 Report Some improvement Remained the same Conditions worsened5 About this Report.

6 2A Letter from the SVCIP Partners ..3 SVCIP Indicator Dashboard ..4 Executive Summary ..6 International Comparisons At A Glance ..8 Innovation Industries Overview ..9 Innovation Assets: Talent ..11 Innovation Assets: Risk Capital and R&D Funding ..15 Innovation Processes: Idea Generation and Commercialization ..18 Innovation Processes: Business Innovation ..19 Outcomes and Prosperity: Business Competitiveness ..21 Outcomes and Prosperity: Quality of Life ..22 Outcomes and Prosperity: Access to Opportunity ..25 Policy Scorecard ..28 Policy Scorecard Progress ..29 Appendix ..30 ContentsExecutive SummaryIn 2015, the Silicon Valley Leadership Group and Silicon Valley Community Foundation joined together to develop the Silicon Valley Competitiveness and Innovation Project (SVCIP) to proactively identify a data-driven, overarching economic strategy to enhance and reinforce the Silicon Valley region s competitive advantages in Innovation , and ensure that Silicon Valley residents have access to the job opportunities and prosperity linked to growth in key industries.

7 Guided by an advisory council and a series of discussions with legislators, business and civic leaders, the SVCIP team developed an Indicator Dashboard and public policy agenda to evaluate and promote the health of Silicon Valley s Innovation ecosystem. The 2017 Report includes a "check up" on the Indicator Dashboard using the most recent data available from 2015 and 2016 as well as progress on the public policy agenda. It also includes new indicators on entrepreneurship and college readiness of the region's high-school students. Data for each of the indicators is compared to key Innovation regions in the , including the New York City metro area, Boston, Southern California, Seattle and Austin, and also to global Innovation regions in a few key areas. The Silicon Valley region is defined as Santa Clara, San Mateo and San Francisco findings: Silicon Valley s Innovation industries continue to set the pace nationally, with 8% growth in 2015. Austin's Innovation industry growth was close at 7%, but Silicon Valley 's growth was double or more than the rate of other regions including New York City (4%), Boston (3%), Seattle (2%), and Southern California (2%).

8 The Valley also continues to have the highest proportion of workers in Innovation industries (26%) among Innovation industries continue to drive the Silicon Valley economy. The cumulative output (gross domestic product) of the region s software, internet and information services, information and communications technology manufacturing, specialized Innovation services, and other Innovation -intensive sectors rose almost 150% in the last decade compared to just under 60% for the rest of the Valley s capital investment in Silicon Valley is down for the first time since 2012 and substantially so. Coming off its 2015 peak, venture capital investment dropped four out of the five quarters, ending in Q3 Valley s Innovation industries created jobs at a faster rate than other Innovation from Silicon Valley 's Innovation industries doubled since capital investment fell 46% between Q3 2015 and Q3 stage investment grows, while the climate for later stage investment worsens.

9 Very early stage funding ( , angel, seed and seed venture capital) was up 22% while Series A investment was down 3% between Q3 2015 and Q3 2016. Only about a quarter of 2014 Silicon Valley start-ups with Series A venture capital investment secured next-stage Series B venture capital funding, compared to 40% of 2012 start-ups. Later stage company median valuation dropped 37%, and IPO valuations dropped more than 70% between 2015 and Valley s talent advantage remains strong, but there are reasons for concern. The Valley has higher worker productivity, a larger percentage of Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) oriented workers in the overall workforce, and the largest share of foreign-born STEM workers compared to other Innovation regions. Yet, the Valley is also experiencing a net domestic out-migration, lagging behind the leading Innovation regions in STEM degrees conferred per capita, and is producing fewer entrepreneurs. Silicon Valley is leaving large numbers of young people behind, without the skills to participate in the region s Innovation industries.

10 Although Hispanic and Latino students comprised the largest ethnic group of Silicon Valley 11th grade test-takers in 2016 (37%), 80% did not meet state standards in mathematics and about half failed to do so in English language arts. Silicon Valley s housing and traffic situation is worsening compared to other Innovation regions. Last year among Innovation regions, only Seattle's housing and rental prices grew faster than Silicon Valley 's. Commute times have lengthened by more than 15% since 2010, compared to 5-11% in other Innovation regions. While Silicon Valley s Innovation industries and foreign talent base remain strong by any measure, the region s ability to sustain its post-recession growth may be eroding. Venture capital investment is off by about 50% from a year ago, along with drops in later-stage funding and valuations. Talented people worldwide still come to Silicon Valley , but rising housing costs, longer commute times, and growing opportunities in other Innovation regions are drawing more residents away.