Sims, Paula - Radford

1 Paula Sims Oh! That a dream so sweet, so long enjoy d , Should be so sadly, cruelly destroy d! Thomas Moore, Lalla Rookh, 1817 Loralei Sims Heather Sims 06/05/86 06/17/86 03/18/89 04/29/89 Information researched and summarized by Deanna Graham and Denise Graham Department of Psychology Radford University Radford , VA 24142-6946 Date Age Life Event 05/21/1959 0 Born in Freeman, Missouri, last of three children, only girl 05/1966 7 Family moved to La Plata, Northeastern Missouri, sexually molested by grandfather 1972 13 Hung out with Randy, shoplifting, drinking and smoking Marijuana, became aggressive 73 /74 /75 13-16 Began having sex during her freshman year. She excelled at basketball and softball. In 1974 she popped pills (mom s Valium); 1975 1975 16 Took LSD with boyfriend Evan Dow. Became interested in bikes and drag racing with brother Randy.

2 Randy took job in Illinois, other brother Dennis had brain surgery for seizures; she used some of his medication. 04/10/1976 17 In a car wreck with Randy, who died at scene at the age of 19. Paula suffered fractures to her face and jaw. Randy s autopsy showed drugs and intoxication. 04/10/1976 17 Started closing herself off from friends and family, liked to be alone often, less aggressive, suicidal ideology. 05/1976 17 Family moved to Wood River, Illinois Cottage Hills. Paula made new friends with June Bland and Rhonda Henson who she met in Civic Memorial High School. These became long-term friendships. 1977 18 Graduated from high school name in yearbook, no picture known as loner 1978 19 Went to Lewis and Clark Community College for a year, keypunch program. She did not finish program. Bought first car, blue 69 Maverick. Went to work as cashier at the National Food Store on Godfrey road in Godfrey.

3 1978/1979 19/20 Song came out called Lorelei , told her friend, June that she was going to name her first daughter Lorelei. Paula often spoke of having children, wanted girls. Her brother Dennis s seizures became worse, causing her mother to become severely depressed. 1979/1980 20/21 Introduced to Robert Rob Sims by her friend June s cousin. Paula and Rob went to rock concert together. 05/02/1981 22 Married Robert Sims 01/1983 24 Rob and Paula moved to Brighton, Illinois 01/1984 25 Called her friend June, and told her that she and Robert were planning on starting a family, because they bought a house and were financially stable. Became friends with Minnie and Don Gray, their neighbors. Minnie and Paula became fast friends, and Paula talked to her about children. 06/05/1986 27 First child, a daughter, Loralei Marie Sims, was born at 6:03 06/17/1986 27 Loralei was stolen from the family s home late at night, supposedly by a man dressed in black, who held a gun on Paula , forcing her to lie on the basement floor, while he then took Loralei from the house.

4 Paula ran to her neighbor s home, the Grays, and told them that Loralei had been taken by someone. Minnie Gray told her husband to call the police. Minnie went back to the Sims home after Paula to stay with her until the police arrived on the scene. She let out the family s dog by accident, and Paula got him back in, stating I can t lose you too. Minnie remembered Paula telling her that the dog barked at anyone who came near their home, and she asked Paula if the dog had barked, because she did not hear him. Paula said that he didn t bark, because he must have been in another room in the basement and did not hear the intruder, which Minnie felt was very weird, because the dog barked all the time, and could not see how a man breaking into their home would go unnoticed by this dog. 06/24/1986 27 Loralei s remains were found. Not sure if actual date, it was week after she was reported kidnapped from her home. The skeletal remains were found 150 feet behind the family s home in the woods.

5 A raccoon had carried the body down the hill. Police were not sure when the baby had died, they theorized maybe two days before she was reported missing by the parents, making them the top suspects in the death of their daughter. 06/14/1986 27 Police later learned after investigating the murder of Loralei, that Paula had taken the baby out to Jack s Hallmark Card Shop, in Jerseyville, the morning of the 14th, which was the day before father s day. Paula had lied to the police, stating she had never taken the baby out of the house. This gave the police reason to doubt the Sims statements about the case. The Sims was already suspects in the police s eyes, and this did not help them. 07/11/1986 27 Detective Gantner told the Post-Dispatch that there was no way to prove that the remains found on June 24th were the remains of Loralei. They were not able to set cause of death either. The only thing they had left to identify the remains was bone marrow to match blood type with the mother.

6 7/1986 27 Detectives Yocom and Plummer decided to contact the FBI, to see if there was another way to identify the remains. They were told of a new kind of test which was available using genetic factors in the blood. The test was only being performed in two laboratories at this time, one in Phoenix, and the other in Atlanta. They chose Dr. Schanfield at the Allo Type Genetic Testing, Inc. laboratory in Atlanta, to do the testing. 08/19/1986 27 Loralei s remains were delivered to the Allo laboratory, along with blood samples from Paula . Ten days later, the results arrived. Detective Yocom read through three pages of the report before finding the answer on the third page, it was Loralei s remains. It was percent certain. Dr. Schanfield had stated that only 95 percent was required to be accepted in court as positive identification of the remains. 09/27/1986 27 Loralei was buried in a private ceremony, at the Woodland Hills Cemetery, in East Alton.

7 01/1987 28 Robert and Paula moved to new home at 1053 Washington Avenue in Alton. 03/12/1987 28 Detective Plummer gave a subpoena to the Sims for more information only. He felt this might also serve as a reminder that the authorities were still watching them. The Sims went to the courthouse in Jerseyville. The Sims s lawyer Mr. Sherwood filed a motion to quash the subpoenas. This motion was denied by Circuit Court Judge Claude Davis. 06/17/1987 29 First anniversary of Loralei s death. 02/01/1988 29 Second child was born, Randall Troy. Named after Paula s brother Randy, and Robert s father Troy. They were very happy at the birth of a Paula stated later on, that she had threatened Randall s life over crying. 03/18/1989 30 Third child, Heather was born. 04/29/1989 30 Heather was reported by Paula to have been taken from their home in Alton late at night. Paula had stated that she was taking out the trash and someone hit her in back of the head.

8 Medical examiner found no forensic evidence to prove that Paula had been struck in the back of the head. Robert had corroborated her story, stating that when he got home she was found lying on the floor, and the baby was gone. They went to look for her, and then called the police. Eerily similar events to three years before, where Paula had stated someone had kidnapped Loralei. 05/03/1989 30 Heather s remains were found at Lock & Dam 26, at Alton lake. Found by Charles Saunders at 7:00 in a trash barrel near the edge of the parking lot, in a black trash bag. The body shows signs of frost bite, where the medical examiner believed she may have been put into a freezer and kept there for a few days. Paula s DNA was found on the trash bag the baby was found in. 01/11/1990 30 Paula is charged with the death of Heather. She was only suspected in the death of Loralei, and was never charged due to lack of forensic evidence. Paula went to court in Peoria, Illinois.

9 Judge Andy Matoesian presided over the case. Prosecutor was Donald Weber, and Defense for Paula was Donald Groshong. The case was in court for a little over two days. The jury deliberated for ten hours. Robert was not charged in the deaths, even though he was suspected of being an accomplice. The police believed he helped hide the babies bodies. 01/31/1990 30 Paula was found guilty of first degree murder in the death of Heather. She was also charged with obstruction of justice and concealing a homicide. No charges had been filed on this date for the death of Loralei, due to lack of forensic evidence. 02/1990 30 Paula admitted to killing her infant daughter Loralei on 06/17/86, and admitted to killing her daughter Heather on 04/29/89. She stated that it was post-partum depression for both deaths, and that she had post-partum with her son Randall, and had threatened him after he would not stop crying one day, but was able to control herself enough to keep from killing him as well.

10 02/1990 30 Paula received a sentence of life without parole. Robert obtained custody of Randall. She was convicted on one count of first degree murder, two counts of obstructing justice, and one count of concealing a homicide, as well as three counts of obstructing justice. 06/11/2001 42 Appeal heard, People vs. Sims, in the Appellate court of Illinois, Fifth district. The appeal was made by Paula stating ineffective assistance of counsel by her attorney Donald Groshong. The judge denied post-conviction relief. She wanted a new trial to prove she suffered from post-partum depression psychosis. 10/17/2006 47 Sims asks the Illinois Prisoner Review Board for clemency. General Information Sex Female Race White Number of victims 2 Country where killing occurred United States States where killing occurred Illinois Cities where killing occurred Alton Type of killer Organized Visionary (heard voices telling her to kill) stated by Paula , "Due to post-partum psychosis I had auditory and visual hallucinations.