統合脅威管理（UTM）スループットパフォーマンスの比較

1 UTM WatchGuard Firebox M270 Cisco Meraki MX84 Fortinet FortiGate 100E sonicwall NSA 2650 Sophos XG 210 2018 2 DR180622E WatchGuard M270 Competitive UTM Copyright 2018 Miercom 2 DR180622E 2018 8 2 .. 3 .. 5 .. 5 .. 8 .. 8 .. 9 .. 11 UDP 1518 UDP IMIX .. 11 HTTP/HTTPS .. 12 Miercom .. 15 .. 15 .. 15 WatchGuard M270 Competitive UTM Copyright 2018 Miercom 3 DR180622E 2018 8 2 UTM VPN Web UTM Miercom WatchGuard Technologies, Inc.

2 Firebox M270 UTM UTM Cisco Meraki MX84 Fortinet FortiGate 100E sonicwall NSA 2650 Sophos XG 210 MSRP Firebox M270 WatchGuard Firebox M370 UTM HTTP HTTPS HTTP HTTPS M270 IMIX UDP Gbps 1518 Gbps UTM HTTP Gbps 48% UTM 661 Mbps 11% WatchGuard M270 Competitive UTM Copyright 2018 Miercom 4 DR180622E 2018 8 2 WatchGuard Firebox M270 Miercom Performance Verified Robert Smithers CEO Miercom WatchGuard M270 Competitive UTM Copyright 2018 Miercom 5 DR180622E 2018 8 2 UTM 1 FW

3 IPS IPS AppCtrl UTM Hypertext Transfer Protocol / HTTP Proxy/AV HTTP get / /AV Hypertext Transfer Protocol Secure HTTPS SSL HTTP/AV HTTPS / UTM UTM IPS AV VPN UTM IT WatchGuard M270 Competitive UTM Copyright 2018 Miercom 6 DR180622E 2018 8 2 WatchGuard Firebox M270 Fortinet FortiGate 100E B1575 Meraki MX84 sonicwall NSA

4 2650 Sophos XG 210 SFOS GA MR-8 WatchGuard Firebox M270 Firebox M270 WatchGuard Firebox 8 1-GE 5 Gbps Intel Quick Assist Technology Intel QAT Intel Atom HTTPS VPN SSL IPSec IPS HTTP HTTPS SMTP DNS sonicwall Network Security Appliance NSA 2650 sonicwall NSA 2600 8 1-GE Gbps IPS URL SSL WatchGuard M270 Competitive UTM Copyright 2018 Miercom 7 DR180622E 2018 8 2 Fortinet FortiGate 100E FortiGate 100E 20 WAN 2 DMZ 1 1 2 14 Gbps IPS 500 Mbps UTM 360 Mbps SSL IPSec IPS Meraki MX84 Meraki MX84 UTM SD-WAN 500 Mbps 320 Mbps UTM SSL

5 IPSec IPS Sophos XG 210 Sophos XG 210 6 14 Gbps Gbps IPS Web WatchGuard M270 Competitive UTM Copyright 2018 Miercom 8 DR180622E 2018 8 2 Miercom DUT UDP HTTP HTTPS UDP HTTP HTTPS / UTM 1 IT Spirent C100-S3.

6 Miercom WatchGuard M270 Competitive UTM Copyright 2018 Miercom 9 DR180622E 2018 8 2 UDP Spirent Test Center Spirent Avalanche Meraki MX84 3 LAN 3 1-GE Spirent Test Center Avalanche DUT 3 LAN 3 1-GE 6 UDP HTTP/S / UDP HTTP HTTPS 6 1-GbE 6 Gbps DUT 250 UDP 2 2 1. 1518 UDP 2.

7 66 594 1518 10,000 IMIX UDP 1 DUP / Mbps 11 6 1-GE LAN UDP 1518 IMIX 100 100 HTTP/HTTPS GET 1 MB .dat :Miercom Spirent Avalanche Traffic Generator UTM DUT WatchGuard M270 Competitive UTM Copyright 2018 Miercom 10 DR180622E 2018 8 2 100 100 1 MB .dat HTTP GET 100 GET 1. HTTP 2. ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 HTTPS 3. AES256-SHA256 HTTPS sonicwall Mbps DUT UTM DUT HTTPS Sophos XG 210 1 Sophos AV Sophos HTTPS FW Sophos IPS HTTPS AV Cisco Meraki HTTPS / 13-14 WatchGuard M270 Competitive UTM Copyright 2018 Miercom 11 DR180622E 2018 8 2 UDP 1518 UDP IMIX

8 Mbps 6 UDP 1518 6 Gbps 2 UDP IMIX 66 594 1518 1: UDP UTM UDP DUT 6 1 GbE 3 3 6 Gbps 1518 WatchGuard Firebox M270 UTM Fortinet Sophos Cisco Meraki 1518 WatchGuard IMIX Gbps.

9 Miercom 566 296 IMIX UDP 1485 296 1317 979 566 1518 UDP 4687 6000 1486 4776 2835 WatchGuard Firebox M270 Cisco Meraki MX84 Fortinet FortiGate 100E sonicwall NSA 2650 Sophos XG 210 979 1317 1485 1486 2835 4776 4687 6000 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 WatchGuard Firebox M270 UTM UDP Mbps Mbps WatchGuard M270 Competitive UTM Copyright 2018 Miercom 12 DR180622E 2018 8 2 HTTP/HTTPS 4 TCP / 7 HTTP HTTP IPS AV 1.

10 FW: HTTP 2. FW +IPS: IPS 3. FW +AV: Web/HTTP AV EICAR 4. FW + AV + IPS: AV IPS 5. UTM: AV IPS Spirent Avalanche 3 HTTP 100 100 100 GET 1MB LAN HTTPS DUT HTTPS ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 sonicwall