Religion and Conflict in Africa - ETH Z

1 DIIS REPORT 2006:61 Religion AND Conflict IN AFRICAWITH A SPECIAL FOCUS ON EAST AFRICABj rn M llerDIIS REPORT 2006:6 DIIS REPORTDANISH INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIONAL STUDIESDIIS REPORT 2006:62 Copenhagen 2006 Danish Institute for International Studies, DIIS Strandgade 56, DK -1401 Copenhagen, DenmarkPh: +45 32 69 87 87 Fax: +45 32 69 87 00E-mail: Design: Carsten Schi lerLayout: Allan Lind J rgensenPrinted in Denmark by Vesterkopi ASISBN: 87-7605-145-5 Price: DKK (VAT included) DIIS publications can be downloaded free of charge from can be ordered at publication is part of DIIS s Defence and Security Studies project which is funded by a grant from the Danish Ministry of rn M ller, Senior Research Fellow, DIIS, Senior Research Fellow, DIIS, Senior Research FellowThe author holds an MA in History and a in International Relations, both from the University of Copenhagen.

2 Since 1985, he has been (senior) research fellow, subsequently programme director at the Copenhagen Peace Research Institute (COPRI), which in 2003 became part of the Danish Institute for International Studies (DIIS). He served as Secretary General of the International Peace Research Association (IPRA) from 1997 to 2000, and has been External Lecturer at the Institute of Political Studies, University of Copenhagen since 1994 and at the Centre of African Studies since 2002. In the academic year 2003/04, he served as Visiting Associate Professor at the research centre on Development and International Relations (DIR) at Aalborg University, where he is pres-ently external lecturer. In addition to being the author of numerous articles and editor of seven anthologies, he is the author of three books.

3 He is presently writing a two-volume book onCivil Wars, Genocides and Interventions. African Confl icts and Confl ict REPORT 2006:63 ContentsAbstract5 Executive Summary6 Preface8 Religion in Sub-Saharan Africa10 Traditional Religion 11 What is Traditional Religion ? 12 Traditional Religion and Anti-Colonial Struggles 13 Traditional Religion in Modern African Societies 15 Traditional Religion in African Civil Wars 17 Islam 19Th e Coming of Islam 19 Islam versus Colonialism 20Th e Present Appeal of Islam 21 Islam and Civil Wars in (West) Africa 23 Christianity 25 Christianity 25 ChristianityChristianity and Colonialism 25 Africanisation of Christianity 30 Africanisation of Christianity 30 Africanisation of ChristianityChristianity, Armed Confl icts and Genocide 33 Summary 35 Summary 35 SummaryReligion, Confl ict and terrorism in East Africa36 Clash of Civilisations/Religions in East Africa ?

4 36 Religious Terrorism in East Africa ? 39 East African Case Studies45 Djibouti 45 Ethiopia 47 From Axum and the Ethiopian Empire to the Dergue 47Th e EPRDF, Ethnicity, Nationalism and Religion 50Th e Present Situation 53 Eritrea 54 Sudan 57 Islam in pre-Independence Sudan 57 Independence and the North-South Confl ict 60Th e CPA and Darfur 65 DIIS REPORT 2006:64 Somalia 67 Islam in Somalia through the Ages 67 Civil War and State Collapse 70 Islam, Confl ict, Terrorism and Counter-Terrorism 72 Kenya 75 Cliterodectomy Crisis and Mau Mau Rebellion 75 Independent Kenya 76Th e Muslim Communities: Fanaticism and/or Terrorism? 78 Tanzania 82 Colonialism and the Maji-Maji 82Th e Independence Compromise 84 Rise of Fanaticism?

5 85 Uganda 86 Colonialism and Christianity 87 Colonialism and Christianity 87 Colonialism and ChristianityCivil Wars: from Independence to Museweni 87 From the War of the Spirit(s) to the Lord s Resistance Army 89 From the War of the Spirit(s) to the Lord s Resistance Army 89 From the War of the Spirit(s) to the Lord s Resistance ArmyConclusion93 Endnotes95 Defence and Security Studies at DIIS 138 DIIS REPORT 2006:65 AbstractTh e report provides a brief overview of the religious landscape of Africa with a special focus on the role of Religion in the continent s several confl icts. It then proceeds to look at East Africa , where the three religious families of traditional Religion , Islam and Christianity are all present in large numbers.

6 It does not fi nd any signifi cant correlation between confl ict propensity or terrorism and Religion , neither in the sense that religious diversity gives rise to any clash of civilizations nor in the sense that the predominance of any one Religion ( Islam) make a country more prone to confl ict or terrorism. It then proceeds to country case studies of Djibouti, Ethiopia, Eritrea, Sudan, Somalia, Kenya, Tanzania and Uganda, providing a brief overview of the history of Religion and confl ict and an assessment of the present situation and the prospects for the REPORT 2006:66 Executive SummaryTh e report provides a brief overview of the religious landscape of Africa , exhibiting a more or less even spread of the three main religious families of traditional religions, Islam and Christianity, and with a predominance of syncretism.

7 Just as Africa may well be the world s most religious continent, it may also be the one where the religions are most elements have been present in many of Africa s confl icts ever since pre-colonial times, just as European colonialism in the late 19th and early 20thcenturies gave rise to resistance movements that were partly inspired by Religion either by traditional religions or Islam. Since independence, religions has also played a role in various armed confl icts, in West Africa . Th e report then zooms in on East Africa , where the three religious families of traditional Religion , Islam and Christianity are all present in large numbers. It does not fi nd any signifi cant correlation between, on the one hand, confl ict propensity or terrorism and, on the other hand, Religion neither in the sense that religious diversity gives rise to any clash of civilizations nor in the sense that the predominance of any one Religion ( Islam) make a country more prone to confl ict or , the report does not fi nd East Africa to be particularly prone to terror-ism.

8 With the exception of the two almost simultaneous terrorist attacks against embassies in Kenya and Tanzania in 1998, terrorism has not been much of a problem in East Africa ; and most of what is sometimes labelled religious terrorism has much more to do with nationalism than with Religion . Th ere is even less support in the available data for the assumption that Islamist terror-ism is a serious problem, as most of the region s religiously-motivated terrorism has been perpetrated by a group calling itself Christian, namely the Lord s Resistance Army in e report then proceeds to country case studies of Djibouti, Ethiopia, Eritrea, Sudan, Somalia, Kenya, Tanzania and Uganda, providing a brief overview of the history of Religion and confl ict and an assessment of the present situation and the prospects for the future.

9 Whereas Religion played a role in the struggle against colonialism in Sudan, Somalia, Kenya and Tanzania, since independence DIIS REPORT 2006:67religion is only found to have been the decisive factor in the confl ict in Sudan, whereas seemingly religious confl icts in other of the region s states really been about something else, either nationalism or politics pure and simple. Even in Sudan, the North-South confl ict contains a number of other elements than re-ligion, a struggle over resources, against marginalisation and for democracy and political rights, while the confl ict in Darfur has virtually nothing to do with Religion , pitting two groups of Muslims against each other. DIIS REPORT 2006:68 PrefaceEven though one might have thought that with modernity and globalisation Religion would recede into the background as far as politics and confl icts are concerned, we seem to be witnessing the exact opposite.

10 Contrary to the fashion-able secularisation thesis, Religion thus seems to be motivating a growing number of people, also as far as their political attitudes and behaviour are concerned and sometimes this even takes the form of violent though these phenomena are not confi ned to the developing world, but are also found in, for instance, the United States, the manifestations tend to be more violent in these peripheral regions , where bizarre spectacles such as riots over Miss World contests in Nigeria, the burning of Danish fl ags and embassies, motivated by a seemingly trivial matter as the printing of caricature drawings of the Prophet, seem to have become the order of the day and where more serious manifestations such as religiously motivated terrorism are also attracting growing attention, mainly because they also aff ect the developed world.